«"If you can look, see. If you can see, observe."» José Saramago

Long before becoming a financial asset, the home was the first expression of human freedom. It was the place where we learned to protect our privacy, build affection, and imagine the future. Perhaps that's why there's a particularly cruel irony in a country that, after denying so many citizens the possibility of owning a home, now seems bothered by finding them on the street.
The recent demonstrations for the right to housing revealed more than just the scale of a social crisis. They exposed the difficult relationship that some political powers and public commentators maintain with one of the most basic manifestations of democracy: the freedom to protest.
The numbers help to understand the discontent and, above all, to dismantle some convenient political narratives. It would be intellectually dishonest to exclusively blame the AD (Democratic Alliance) for a housing crisis that worsened during the PS (Socialist Party) governments. But it would be equally dishonest to ignore that, since the change of government, the indicators have deteriorated significantly. According to the National Institute of Statistics, housing prices increased by 8.2% in 2023, the last full year of socialist governance, 9.1% in 2024, the transition year, and 17.6% in 2025, already entirely under the AD. In the second quarter of 2026, the year-on-year increase remained at 16.5%. These are price growth rates, not direct measures of affordability, and do not allow us to attribute all the evolution to the policies of a single government. But they reveal an inescapable reality: a problem that the Socialist Party failed to solve continued to worsen under the Democratic Alliance, with a particularly pronounced acceleration in 2025. Political responsibility is not erased by alternation of power, nor does the inherited legacy constitute perpetual absolution. After all, governing is not only about explaining the past, but also about being accountable for the present.
Faced with this situation, thousands of Portuguese people took to the streets. Young people, workers, mothers with children, elderly people who may no longer need a home, but retain something equally important: the capacity to care for those who have not yet achieved one. They carried signs, tents, music and slogans. The vast majority did not bring the violence that some seem so keen to attribute to them.
This doesn't mean everything was done well. I saw protesters vandalizing public property, behavior I condemn without reservation. Those who did it must be identified and held accountable. It shouldn't be difficult to achieve that. But I also saw a police officer push a protester who was calmly standing at his feet, posing no visible threat, an action that even warranted a reprimand from superiors. The authority seemed bothered not by the citizen's violence, but by his tranquility. As if the absence of resistance constituted, in itself, an intolerable form of insubordination.
Neither episode should serve to absolve the other. Vandalism does not become legitimate simply because it stems from a just demand, just as a uniform does not automatically transform force into reason. Democracy demands responsibility from those who protest and, precisely because it entrusts the police with the legitimate monopoly of force, it demands even greater discernment from them.
It is in this context that Luís Neves emerges as particularly revealing. The Minister of Internal Administration seems to have discovered in the demonstrations an opportunity to reaffirm an authority that the controversies related to his time at the Judiciary Police had helped to weaken. Before the demonstrators, the law must be followed with almost liturgical rigor. However, when faced with questions regarding internal procedures of the institution he led, he admitted the existence of informal practices, while also acknowledging that certain acts should have been formalized.
These are legally distinct situations, and any responsibilities yet to be determined should not be anticipated. Nevertheless, the political contradiction warrants reflection: why can informality be understood within the corridors of institutions, while a stricter interpretation of the law becomes indispensable when peaceful citizens occupy a public square?
The irony takes on historical dimensions when we recall that the decree regulating the right to assembly and demonstration, Decree-Law No. 406/74, was created during the government of Vasco Gonçalves. A law from the revolutionary period, conceived to frame the exercise of a newly won freedom, is now invoked by a center-right government to justify restrictive interventions against those who protest. History, when not studied, amuses itself by playing tricks on its protagonists.
Even more curious is observing the rapprochement, at least rhetorically, between Luís Neves and the security-focused discourse of Chega, after months of mutual criticism. The language of authority seems to have acquired an extraordinary capacity to reconcile old antagonisms. Perhaps because it is always easier to demonstrate firmness before citizens sitting in a square than before the structural problems that brought them there.
Another disconcerting spectacle unfolded outside the streets…
Some political commentators rushed to label the protesters as hooligans, delinquents, smelly, tattooed, dirty, or simply people with nothing better to do. The poverty of vocabulary revealed an even greater poverty of thought. After all, for some, the people are an admirable entity as long as they remain abstract; they become inconvenient when they appear in flesh and blood, wearing clothes we don't approve of and making demands that disturb our peace. In this context, a Palestinian flag seems more serious than a beating of a defenseless citizen.
We want politically engaged young people, as long as they don't cause trouble. We want a dynamic civil society, as long as it remains silent. We defend freedom of expression, as long as no one demonstrates in a place where we can observe.
It's a curious conception of democracy: the right to protest seems to end precisely at the moment when the protest begins to fulfill its function.
And perhaps all this reveals a deeper cultural deficiency. One of the consequences of reading few books is not only the impoverishment of language; it is the progressive loss of the capacity to inhabit, even if only for moments, the lives of others. Literature teaches us what no political conviction should dispense with: that our experience does not constitute the universal measure of the human condition.
Dostoevsky doesn't ask us to absolve his characters; he compels us to understand the complexity of their motives. Saramago reminds us of the fragility of collective certainties. Victor Hugo shows us that legality and justice can be found on opposite sides of the same barricade.
Reading, in this sense, is an exercise in intellectual humility. It is recognizing that a person may have reasons we don't know, sufferings we haven't experienced, and needs that our privileges have exempted us from understanding.
Those who have never struggled to pay rent don't need to agree with all the proposals of housing movements. They only need to admit that the inability to find a home can be a serious enough reason to take to the streets. Empathy doesn't require ideological adherence. It requires imagination.
However, what happened is what is politically most convenient for those who cannot solve the problem: we stopped discussing housing and started discussing the protesters. Attention shifted from rents to tents, from wages to batons, from public policies to public order. And so, while we discuss the legality of remaining in a square, we forget to ask why so many Portuguese people can no longer find another place to live.
A police operation can disperse a demonstration. It cannot disperse the reasons that caused it.
The comparison with France, evoked in the televised debate by Sérgio Sousa Pinto on CNN, makes the episode even more disturbing. Portugal maintains a tradition of relatively peaceful protest. Even when reprehensible behavior occurs, we are far from the intensity of the confrontations and destruction that occasionally accompany large French mobilizations.
If the response to demonstrations dominated by music, dance, and peaceful protest already demands such a show of force, what response would we reserve for protests of another dimension?
The question is uncomfortable because it reveals how easily we confuse authority with authoritarianism, order with obedience, and public tranquility with social silence.
A democracy does not demonstrate its maturity by its ability to disperse protesters, but by the intelligence with which it distinguishes between inconvenience and threat. And a truly strong state does not need to transform every act of disobedience into a power struggle.
Ultimately, an irony remains that should shame us: in a country where so many citizens can no longer find space inside a house, we are also beginning to discuss how much space we should grant them outside of it.
And, returning to Sérgio Sousa Pinto's provocation, if a demonstration with music, dancing, and no widespread violence deserves this police response, what would happen if we imported the French protests?
Would we use missiles?
Leave a Reply