“A God is born. Others die. Truth neither came nor went: Error changed. We now have another Eternity, And what has passed was always better. Blind, Science tills the useless soil. Mad, Faith lives the dream of its worship. A new God is just a word. Do not seek nor believe: all is hidden.”
Fernando Pessoa
Plutarch recounts that, in the 1st century BC, Quintus Sertorius was offered a white doe. The Roman general, then campaigning in Hispania, quickly realized that the animal's rarity could be worth more to him than its beauty. He tamed it and convinced his soldiers that it had been sent by Diana and that, through it, the goddess of the hunt revealed the future to him. When Sertorius's informants secretly brought him good news, the general would have the doe appear and attribute what his spies had told him to divine intervention.
The doe didn't need to speak to Diana; it was enough for the men to believe that she spoke. Perhaps few things define us as profoundly as this capacity to believe in what we cannot prove. The gods, the rituals, and the answers we seek in them have changed. What remains is the need to find meaning in what the eyes alone cannot explain.
Few Portuguese cities seem to coexist so naturally with this uncertain boundary between history and legend as Évora. In what was then Roman Ebora, the city's memory is also linked to Sertorius, a Roman general who would paradoxically end up fighting against the power of Rome itself. He sided with one of the defeated factions in the Republic's civil wars, and when Sulla seized power and persecuted his adversaries, Sertorius found a place of resistance in western Hispania. Among the Lusitanians he found allies, and in Ebora a new base for his struggle. For years, this Roman fought the armies sent by Rome while seeking to build, far from the capital, another idea of Rome.
Perhaps that is why her story belongs so well to Évora: because it too seems to exist in that territory where borders blur. Between center and periphery, victor and vanquished, fact and legend, ally and enemy, men and gods. Almost fifteen centuries after the white doe, no one sought Diana in these lands anymore. Rome had disappeared, other peoples had crossed the Peninsula, and another God had taken the place of the ancients.
This time, the extraordinary chose a thorn bush. Tradition tells that, around 1400, Our Lady appeared to a shepherd above a thorn bush on the outskirts of Évora. Some versions add that the bush burned without being consumed, an image that inevitably reminds us of Moses' burning bush.
We will never know what the shepherd saw. Perhaps that's not even the most interesting question. Because what happened afterward can be touched. Devotion grew, pilgrims arrived, and in 1412, a small hermitage was built. Decades later, the church and convent of the Hieronymite monks would appear. The belief had materialized in stone.
King Afonso V became devoted to Our Lady of the Thorn. King João II frequented the convent and ordered the construction of a guesthouse next to the church for his stays. Kings, princesses, and nobles passed through those doors and added new stories to the one that began with a shepherd and a tree.
One of them is particularly delicious…
In 1490, the court was in Évora for the marriage of Prince Afonso, son of King John II, to Isabel of Aragon, daughter of the Catholic Monarchs. According to tradition preserved by the convent, the prince visited his future wife before the marriage was consummated, and they both decided to, let's say, rehearse the pleasurable conjugal duties before receiving divine authorization to fulfill them.
That night, a storm struck the monastery, and a boulder fell upon the prince's chambers. For the monks, there was no doubt: God had just given his opinion on the aforementioned anticipation.
When, months later, King Afonso died in a fall from his horse, the coincidence became even easier to transform into providence.
Perhaps that's what we've always done. Faced with chance, we seek a narrative. We connect events, look for causes, invent meanings. Because a story, even an improbable one, is often more comforting than admitting that certain things simply happen.
It was with some of these stories in mind that we crossed the gates of the... more than six hundred years after the first hermitage. Convento do Espinheiro Historic Hotel & Spa.
The monks left after the extinction of religious orders, but much of the convent remained. And that is the first great quality of this five-star hotel near Évora: it doesn't use history merely as decoration. It lets us enter into it.
The complex currently comprises 92 rooms, including 10 suites (we stayed in the Garcia de Resende Suite), distributed between the historic wing and a contemporary wing. The latter offers a decidedly modern interpretation, while the former inevitably holds greater allure. In a place like this, the irregularity of a wall can be worth more than much carefully studied design.
The comfort level meets expectations for the category, but it would be strange to choose the Thorn bush not just by the size of the room or the obvious quality of the bed. Indoor and outdoor swimming pools, gym, tennis courts, extensive gardens and the Diana Spa, With massages and treatments, they complete a very competent leisure offer. The old Gothic cistern has found a second life linked to wine, and the preserved cloisters, church, and convent spaces mean that a simple walk through the hotel can turn into a discovery.
This is the true luxury of Thorn bush. Not what was added, but what they had the intelligence not to remove. And this coexistence between past and present continues at the table. Divine It occupies the former wine cellar of the convent, in an extraordinary 36-meter room, divided into three naves under ribbed vaults. The cuisine is clearly inspired by the Alentejo region, but seeks to do so without confusing tradition with repetition.
We started with Black Iberian Pork and Acorn — Black Iberian Pork Terrine, Acorn Purée and Coastal Prawns. Pork and acorn belong to the same landscape before they belong to the same dish. The prawn breaks this predictability with a delicate, maritime note. It's a deeply territorial starter without becoming folkloric.
Even more interesting was the Dogfish and Coriander — Dogfish Broth, Coriander, Fried Dogfish, Cured Dogfish, Fried Bread and Roasted Garlic Purée. Dogfish, bread, garlic, and coriander belong to the most basic vocabulary of Alentejo cuisine. Divinus doesn't alter the language, it changes its grammar. The fish appears in different preparations, the bread gains texture, the garlic sweetness, and the coriander immediately returns us to where the dish originated.
Perhaps this is the smartest way to modernize a tradition: transform it enough to spark curiosity, but never to the point of no longer recognizing oneself in the mirror.
In the main ones, the Sea bass and lobster — Sea bass, lobster, shellfish rice and roasted sea bass jus It is built upon the accumulation of maritime flavors. The sea bass brings delicacy, the lobster sweetness and opulence, the rice concentrates the flavor of the bivalves, and the jus adds depth. A dish that doesn't seek contrast, but rather intensity.
With the Lamb — Lamb, Peas and Black Pork Sausage We return to the land. Simpler in description, perhaps for that very reason very coherent: the identity of the lamb, the freshness and vegetal sweetness of the peas, and the cured intensity of the sausage come together in a dish that doesn't need technical excesses to justify its place.
We finished with Almond, Pear and Lemon Verbena — Almond Financier, Pear Pickle, Lemon Verbena Mousse, Spice Infusion and Almond Ice Cream. After a meal dominated by deep flavors, dessert chooses aroma, acidity, and delicacy. Almond gives it structure, pear oscillates between sweetness and acidity, and lemon verbena cleanses and perfumes.
Dinner doesn't end with an exclamation point. It ends with ellipses…
The next day we exchanged the solemnity of the Divine for the cloisters and a small handwritten letter of tapas: Octopus, Feather Strips, Quail Eggs, Rabbit à la St. Christopher, and Head Cheese.
I particularly liked this other side of Thorn bush. Less ceremonial, more relaxed, but still deeply connected to the territory. Eating head cheese and rabbit in the cloister of a five-star hotel might seem a slight contradiction; in reality, it may be a demonstration of coherence. Sophistication doesn't mean erasing the origin of things.
And sitting there, before dishes that could belong to the memory of an old Alentejo kitchen, the convent seemed to make even more sense.
A place truly survives when it no longer needs to be contemplated from a distance. When we continue to pass through it. To converse there. To eat there. To drink there. To sleep there. Admit it, you're already afraid of the next verb 😛
The Convent of Espinheiro is not perfect because it is old, nor extraordinary simply because kings passed through its rooms. Its merit lies in how it manages to remain alive without needing to hide what it once was.
And perhaps that is why, as I was leaving, I thought again of Sertorius's doe and the shepherd before the thorn bush. We don't know if Diana ever spoke through a doe. We don't know what the shepherd truly saw.
Not even if God cared about the "rubbing" of two young lovers to the point of throwing a piece of church at them.
Or perhaps the problem lies in the wrong verb.
Because believing also means admitting that not everything that is true needs to fit within what we can demonstrate. Perhaps the shepherd simply looked at a thorn bush. Perhaps he saw what he said he saw. Between one possibility and the other lies that immense territory where reason ends without necessarily ending truth.
I, who believe, do not need to choose between legend and history, just as I do not need to choose between faith and reason. I prefer to think that both seek, with different instruments, to approach questions that have always accompanied us.
Whatever the answer, in that place men believed. They walked there. They built. They prayed. They loved. They ate. They slept. We did some of those same things… six centuries later. And, at least in our conversations and in our thoughts, Sertorius and his white doe, Diana and the shepherd, princes and kings returned, for a moment, to live within those walls.
And when we left the Thorn Convent I thought that perhaps faith isn't about believing in the impossible, but about accepting that what is possible may be greater than what we can explain.
For many, Our Lady never appeared in that thorn bush. Reason demands proof, and perhaps it would do well to ask for it.
But... maybe it has appeared.
Because not everything we cannot prove is necessarily untrue. Between what we know and what we believe lies a territory that no science has been able to fully map. We call it mystery. Some call it faith.
And perhaps it is precisely in that space, in that small and immense "perhaps," that man has always raised his eyes when reason can no longer take him any further.
Sometimes he finds only the sky. Other times he finds God. And, from time to time, he lowers his gaze again, picks up a stone and builds a cathedral, hoping to lessen the distance between them.
If you ask me if this is how it all happened, after Sertorius and the doe, Diana and the shepherd, princes, kings, legends, stones and six centuries of faith, I still only have one answer:
Absolutely, maybe.
Leave a Reply